Well, I've just finished reading Allegient by Veronica Roth.
I read all three books in the series in about 10 days so when I got to the end of the last book and felt oddly unsatisfied about it I thought that it was because I read through too fast and didn't get the all nuances or whatever but then I read
this post and it summed up how I felt about the book.
I actually watched Divergent for the first time last month, before I'd read any of the books. This was a huge departure for me since I've always been fairly strict about reading the book before I watch the movie. Usually anytime I'd go to watch a book-based-movie I'd know how the story would unfold, no real surprises, it was more a question of execution, did the movie capture the essence of the book, how were the visual effects, etc.
But in this case, I had no idea about the plot, the characters, anything. All I knew was that the main character was called Tris and it was being hailed as 'the new Twilight", which is probably why I hadn't bothered to read the books in the first place.. So it was quite exciting to enter this new, unknown world, watching the opening scene, entering the city, listening to the voice-over and not knowing what was going to happen next. Right from the start I loved the soundtrack and the sense of freedom it invoked...the zip-lining scene was awesome and Run, boy, run- by Woodkid is my new anthem for getting in the zone when I need to get stuff done.
I enjoyed the movie so much I went out and got the books. I was interested to see how the book characters and plot compared to that of the movie. I was looking forward to reading about a strong, smart, brave young woman but I think movie Tris came across as much stronger than book Tris. In the books, Tris often struck me as less together, more whiny than movie Tris. I expected more from someone who left Abnegation of her own accord to go to Dauntless...she's supposed to be badass... And yeah, I get that book Tris is 16 while Shailene Woodley is 23-ish but still, that was annoying. I guess I'm still looking for a character who I can really relate to...starting to think I'm going to have to write her myself. But I like what Shailene Woodley has done with the character so I'm looking forward to watching the rest of the series.
Anyway, the whole point of this journal entry is- WTH? I feel like I've been duped with the POV Chapters in Allegient switching between Tris and Four. Like, I should have known... SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!!
SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!! SPOILERS!!!
SPOILERS!!! I should have known that Tris was going to die...Divergent was told solely from Tris's point of view and then its like halfway through writing the last book the author decided she would be killing off her main character but the story would need to go on for a bit after her death so she needed someone else to tell the story after Tris's death. So she just backtracks and inserts Four POV chapters as a kind of sleight of hand thing thing...but its so obvious in hindsight.
I think its more annoying because I like the idea, the premise, and I think it could have been better written, a different ending might have served the story better. I think I would have preferred Tris live but maybe the author killed her off as a way to set this story apart from all other dystopian-young-adult trilogies. I hope that's not the only reason though like, "Ok Katniss, Peeta, Gale, Bella, Jacob and Edward they all survive so I'm going to do something different. I'm going to kill off my main characters, so there! MwahahahahHAHAHAHAHAH!!!"
Also annoying was the fact that I kept getting confused about which characters POV I was reading. Tris and Four 'sounded' like the same person. You know how there's a voice in your head when you read, its a different voice for different characters but for me reading Allegient, this voice was the same, it didn't change between Tris and Four. They used the same words, I had to keep checking whose POV I was reading. Are they so in tune with each other, so perfectly right for each other that they even think the same way?? Nope, not buying it, this was a problem with the writing.
Having said all that, good on Veronica Roth for coming up with an idea and executing it, she's a published author and now has movies based on her books. That's quite an achievement. It gives me hope that I can one day get a book written and published, and secure a movie deal